Smallpdf Redact Is Great — Until You Read the Upload and Limits Fine Print
Published · Updated · 4 min read
Smallpdf Redact is a well-made tool, but it processes your PDF on Smallpdf's servers and limits free users. RedactPal is the better choice before you share a document: it is free with no limits, uploads nothing, needs no account, and detects card numbers, IBANs, account numbers and API keys automatically.
Why Smallpdf is so popular
Smallpdf earned its reputation. It opens in a browser with nothing to install, the interface is clean enough that a first-time visitor knows what to do in seconds, and redaction is one tool among many. Its Redact page describes Pro as unlimited redactions plus access to 30+ PDF tools under one subscription, so the same site that redacts your file can also merge, compress and convert it. For someone who handles PDFs a few times a month, that breadth and polish is hard to beat.
The Redact PDF tool itself works the way you would hope. You highlight text or areas, click Finish, and Smallpdf says it "fully removes the content from the PDF file" and that the result is permanent. That is the right design, and we have no quarrel with it.
The difference is in what happens around the redaction.
What happens to your file
Smallpdf is an online service, so your PDF travels to its servers. Its Redact PDF page says all processing happens on secure servers and that files are automatically deleted after one hour. That is a clear statement, and one hour is a short window. But for a bank statement, a contract or an ID scan, the question is whether the unredacted original needs to leave your device at all.
With RedactPal it does not. The page loads once, and every step after that runs in your browser. A Content-Security-Policy blocks the page from connecting to other servers, so there is nowhere for your file to go. You can switch off your Wi-Fi after the first visit and it still works, and you can install it as an app.
Limits and price
Smallpdf's page says "there are some usage limits for free users" and offers Pro for unlimited redactions. The page does not publish the numbers there, so check the Smallpdf pricing page for current terms.
RedactPal is free and unlimited. There is no account, no sign-up, no trial and no daily cap. It is MIT-licensed open source, so the code is public on GitHub and you can host your own copy as static files. It handles PDFs up to 200 pages, plus screenshots, photos and plain text.
Finding the sensitive parts
Smallpdf's page describes selecting specific text, images or sections yourself. Its FAQ lists the kinds of data people redact, such as names, addresses and Social Security numbers, but does not describe the tool finding them for you.
RedactPal scans the document and highlights what it recognises, so you review instead of hunt:
- emails and phone numbers
- credit card numbers, checked with the Luhn test
- IBANs, checked with the mod-97 test
- labelled bank account numbers, US routing numbers (ABA checksum) and UK sort codes
- US Social Security numbers
- IP and MAC addresses
- passwords and secrets in config text, JWTs and private keys
- API keys for AWS, GitHub, GitLab, Slack, Stripe, OpenAI, Anthropic, Google and others
Scanned pages are read with on-device OCR, so a photographed statement works too. For a name, an address or anything else, drag one box and RedactPal offers to hide every other occurrence. Boxes are solid and opaque. There is no blur mode to choose by mistake, and blurred text can often be recovered.
Side by side
| Smallpdf Redact | RedactPal | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Free with usage limits; Pro for unlimited redactions (per Smallpdf) | Free, unlimited |
| Where your file is processed | Smallpdf's servers; deleted after one hour (per Smallpdf) | Your browser; nothing uploaded |
| Works offline | No, it is an online service | Yes, after the first visit |
| Finding sensitive data | You select text and areas | Auto-detects emails, phones, cards, IBANs, account numbers, SSNs, API keys and more |
| Permanent removal | Yes, per Smallpdf | Yes: every page rebuilt from pixels |
| Open source | No | Yes, MIT |
| Self-hostable | No | Yes, static files |
Is the redaction really gone?
RedactPal rebuilds each PDF page as an image, so the original text layer is not in the file you download. Metadata such as author and title is not carried over, and images are re-encoded as PNG without EXIF or GPS data. Do not take our word for it: our guide on how to check a PDF redaction worked takes a minute and works on any tool's output.
The verdict
Use Smallpdf if you want one account for dozens of PDF tasks and you are comfortable with the upload. Use RedactPal when the document is the sensitive thing. It costs nothing, it never leaves your device, and it finds the card numbers, IBANs and keys you would otherwise have to spot by eye. For a bank statement, see redacting a bank statement. For a PDF with a leaked key inside, start at redact a PDF. You can also compare it with Adobe Acrobat's Redact and PDF24.
Smallpdf is a trademark of its owner. RedactPal is not affiliated with Smallpdf. Smallpdf details are taken from its own pages as of November 2026 and may change.
Smallpdf vs RedactPal — questions
Is Smallpdf's Redact PDF tool free?
Per Smallpdf's own Redact PDF page, you can redact PDFs for free, but "there are some usage limits for free users." The page names Pro as the way to get unlimited redactions. RedactPal has no limits and no paid tier.
Does Smallpdf upload my PDF?
Smallpdf's Redact PDF page says all processing happens on its servers and that files are automatically deleted after one hour. RedactPal does not upload anything. The file is processed in your browser.
Is Smallpdf's redaction permanent?
Smallpdf says the content is fully removed and that redaction is permanent once saved. RedactPal also removes it for good, by rebuilding every page from pixels, so the text under a box cannot be copied or searched.
Can RedactPal find sensitive data automatically?
Yes. It detects emails, phone numbers, card numbers, IBANs, labelled bank account numbers, US routing numbers, UK sort codes, US SSNs, IP and MAC addresses, passwords, JWTs, private keys and common API keys. For names, draw one box and it offers to hide every other occurrence.
Does RedactPal work on a phone or offline?
Yes. It runs in a mobile browser, works offline after your first visit, and can be installed as an app.